How The Oil Industry Did Financially In 1991
— Prospects For The Future — The oil industry had a disappointing year in 1991—the combined profits of the leading 20 oil companies were more than 20 percent belowthe income earned in 1990. Total sales of the oil companies in 1991 fell by more than four percent—the first time sales have fallen since 1986. The oil industry has been hurt by the recession, as consumers bought less gasoline and depressed industries reduced their demand for other petroleum products and petrochemicals.
In 1991, the profitability of the industry fell to a 9.8 percent return on stockholders' equity, or only a 3.2 percent return on total sales (see Fig. 1). However, the worldwide profitability of U.S. oil companies masks the extremely low earnings they've been able to achieve here in the United States. The low rate of return in the United States is largely due to a poor investment climate for exploration and development: • Political and regulatory restrictions are limiting access to the most promising lands for exploration, • The political risk has increased even if oil or gas is discovered, because production could be halted or constrained by regulation, reducing the value of the find, and • Tax law in the United States is not as favorable to industry as tax laws in many other countries.
Largely because other countries have actively encouraged exploration, U.S. oil companies are investing massive amounts of capital overseas.
In 1990, for the first time, over half of the exploration and production spending of U.S. oil companies went toward developing new oil and gas resources outside the United States.
Oil Company 1991 Financial Results API aggregates the financial results for 20 leading oil companies to give a picture of industry trends.
The 1991 figures for API's sample of oil companies show that: • Total revenues declined 4.4 percent.
from $425.7 billion in 1990 to $406.9 billion in 1991. Nineteenninety- one was the first year since 1968 in which the revenue declined.
Fourth quarter 1991 revenues were 18.7 percent below fourth quarter 1990 revenues.
• Net income, or income after interest and taxes, was $13.2 billion for all of 1991, a 20.7 percent drop from 1990s $16.6 billion. Net income in the fourth quarter of 1991 dropped 34.8 percent below the fourth quarter of 1990. Eight companies sawtheir profits drop by more than 60 percent, and of those, four companies had more than an 80 percent drop in their net income in 1991. Three other firms had actual losses.
• The oil industry had a profitability rate of 9.8 percent in 1991, measured as the ratio of net income to stockholders'equity, down from 12.8 percent one year earlier. The oil industry's earnings as a percentage of total sales dropped from 3.9 percent in 1990 to 3.2 percent in 1991.
Oil Companies Did Marginally Better Than Non-Oil Companies The poor performance of the oil industry looks only slightly better when compared with the financial beating taken by the nation's other manufacturing companies in 1991 as a result of the recession. The net income of 100 leading non-oil companies tracked by API plummented by 59.7 percent in 1991 from 1990s level. In just the fourth quarter of 1991, their net income fell by 72.4 percent from the same quarter one year earlier.
The poor earnings of the manufacturing companies were strongly influenced by the huge losses posted by the auto companies and IBM. The profitability of the manufacturing companies (net income as a percent of stockholders' equity) fell from 13.0 percent in 1990to 5.1 percent in 1991.
Low Domestic Earnings Key To Poor Oil Industry Performance Looking at a more detailed breakdown of the operating earnings of the 20 U.S. oil companies reveals some very important trends. Although many of these companies have important chemical, coal and other energy operations, the petroleum sectors of exploration, production, refining, marketing and trans- portation are their core businesses.
The worldwide petroleum sector earnings of the 20 U.S. oil companies declined by 19.9 percent from 1990 to 1991. Within that, domestic petroleum earnings fell 35.5 percent, whereas earnings from the foreign petroleum operations of U.S.
oil companies declined only 1.9 percent.
As a result, in 1990, U.S. petroleum operations provided the oil companies with 53.6 percent of their worldwide earnings. But in 1991, only 43.2 percent of worldwide petroleum sector earnings were generated in the United States. Or put another way, earnings originating outside the United States rose from 46.4 percent of worldwide in 1990 to 56.8 percent in 1991 (see Fig. 2).
Overseas Investment As Much As Five Times More Profitable Several factors are responsible for this shift. One reason is that other countries, particularly those in Europe and the Far East, havenotbeen hit as hard by the current recession as the United States. As a result, refining and marketing (downstream) earnings have held up better overseas than in the United States.
Probably a more important trend, however, is the declining profitability of U.S. domestic exploration and production (upstream) investments.
A September 1991 study by First Boston Corp. found that "operating earnings per dollar of net property, plant and equipment outside the United States are several times greater than the same measure in the United States." In fact, according to that study, earnings overseas were as much as five times the rate of earnings in the United States.
Investment Overseas Will Mean Fewer U.S. Jobs In response, U.S. oil companies are being forced to look for their future abroad. The facts are that: • The foreign exploration and development expenditures ofU.S. companies have nearly doubled since 1986, growing from less than 30 percent of worldwide spending in the mid-1980s to over 50 percent in 1990.
• While the four major oil companies that already have large foreign sectors increased their investment overseas by a modest 15 percent from 1987 to 1990, the 14 oil companies that have historically operated in the U.S. tripled their investment overseas duringthe same three-year period.
Because of a variety of circumstances, primarily economic and government policies, the American petroleum industry has been forced to curtail its domestic operations.
As a result, over the past ten years the industry has lost 326,000jobs, or 17 percent of total employment.
The exploration and development sector of the petroleum industry has been hit the hardest—with 300,000 jobs lost from 1981 to 1991, a falloff of over 40 percent.
On March 2, 1992, an article in The New York Times addressed the issue: "Many industry executives and financial analysts said that the tally of jobs pared from oil and gas production in the United States since the peak month of the last drilling boom, January 1982, could exceed 400,000 by the end of this year, far more than the number lost in the same period in the American auto industry." One seemingly lost opportunity to create needed jobs and develop important energy resources is the development of the coastal plain of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR). While oil exploration and development would leave a footprint the size of Dulles Airport in a frozen tract the size of South Carolina, ANWR operations at their peak level could create as many as 735,000jobs across the United States. These potential jobs —now apparently lost— would have provided work in exploration, development, transportation, refining, equipment manufacturing, and indirect support industries in all 50 states.
Without an improvement in the investment climate in the United States, the trend toward overseas investment is unlikely to be reversed.
Over the longer term, this "exporting" of the U.S. oil industry means fewer U.S. jobs, lost tax revenues, and increased dependence on imported energy.
Other stories from April 1992 issue
- Council Suggests DOD Actions To Benefit US Yards page: 6
- AWO Testifies At USCG User Fee Hearing page: 6
- SPD Technologies Elects Colangelo President page: 8
- Renk Tacke Wins Planetary Gear Unit Order From Mitsubishi page: 8
- Sea-Fab Building Two Oil Skimmers For California Co-Op page: 9
- Syncrolift Shiplift Used To Launch HMS Vanguard page: 10
- Frotronics Adds Safecom CM And CP To List Of Products Marketed For Philips page: 11
- Trinity Industries Delivers Two Hydrographic Survey Ships To U.S. Navy page: 11
- MSRC Hosts Reception In N e w York City page: 12
- Comsat Corporation Names C. Thomas Faulders III Vice President And CFO page: 15
- Three Circuit Breaker Seminars Offered By SPD Technologies page: 16
- 1993 International Oil Spill Conference Issues Call For Papers page: 19
- Deerberg Offers Literature On Waste Management And Interior Design page: 20
- OTC PREVIEW Offshore Industry's Largest Show Slated For May 4-7 In Houston page: 23
- USCG Orders Differential GPS Equipment From Magnavox page: 30
- NKK, Hitachi Zosen Cooperate To Build Technigaz LNG Carriers page: 30
- U.S. Cruise Ships Poised To Sail To Havana Should Castro Be Ousted page: 31
- Subic Naval Base Losing Its Drydocks page: 31
- C.F. Laborde Elected Senior VP, Co-General Counsel Of Tidewater page: 31
- MMS Receives Five Ship Contract From Oglebay Norton page: 31
- DEVELOPING A NATIONAL ENERGY POLICY page: 32
- First Spill Response Vessel Launched For MSRC By Bender Shipbuilding page: 34
- MARINE SPILL RESPONSE CORPORATION page: 35
- Erie Basin Bargeport Opens page: 36
- U.S. Naval Academy Acquires Eight ECO Bridge Simulators page: 36
- IHI's Contra rotating Propeller To Be Installed On VLCC Scheduled For Commissioning In 1993 page: 38
- Nichols Delivers 76-Person Ferry For Use By Saipan's Grand Hotel page: 39
- Arkhon Offers Brochure Detailing Marine Consultant Services page: 40
- ABS Holds Seminar On Tanker Designs Of The Future page: 41
- ABS Signs Agreement To Advance Phoenix World City Project page: 42
- Growing Cruise Market: 10 Million Passengers By The Year 2000 page: 45
- New Vicmar Fuel System Could Save Operators Millions Of Dollars page: 45
- PSRY Now Major Center For Cruise Ship Destination, Repair And Conversion page: 45
- SPD Battery Monitoring System Praised By Canadian DOD page: 46
- Intervention/ROV '92 Set For June 10-12 In San Diego, Calif. page: 46
- Det norske Veritas Authorized For U.S. Tonnage Admeasurement page: 47
- WesTech, Cosworth Sign Licensing Agreement For Closed Cycle Systems page: 47
- Chevron Christens New Tanker In Brazil page: 48
- Rolla Offers 20-Page "Guide To Fast Propellers/ And 4-Page, Color Brochure page: 48
- Comsat Expands SeaMail With Instant Electronic News In Seven Languages page: 51
- Krupp MaK Engines Ordered For Three Hurtigruten-Line Ferries page: 51
- Dry Dock Association Formed As Ship Repair Revives In N ew York page: 52
- Two Former East German Shipyards To Be Sold By Privatizing Agency page: 52
- Zidell Marine Launches Second Of Two Chip Barges page: 54
- Nelson Supplies Bilge Equipment For New MSRC Vessels page: 54
- Bisso Adds New Tug To Its Fleet Of Vessels page: 56
- Lanng & Stelman Develop N e w Remote Monitoring System page: 56
- Midland Offers Liquid Level Overfill Alarm System For Tank Barges page: 57
- Harrison County Voters In Mississippi Approve Dockside Gambling page: 57
- World's Largest Fish Pump For Chile page: 60
- DOT Releases Port Needs Study page: 60
- ASNE DAY 92 page: 61
- COMMERCIAL SHIPBUILDING—DIVERSIFICATION AND GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES FOR NAVY SUPPLIERS page: 71
- AWO Urges Change In USCG User Fees Proposal page: 72
- Alaska Considers Exemption To Direct Action Requirement page: 72
- Motorola Introduces Line Of Portable Marine Radios page: 74
- MSI Awarded $9 Million Navy Simulator Contract page: 75
- Joint Venture Formed By McDermott, Shelfproekstroi page: 75
- Oil Industry Warns US Of Looming Price Shock page: 76
- Tanker Operators Asking Charterers To Cover Oil Spill Costs page: 76
- Jotun Coatings For All Statoil Platforms page: 76
- U n i t o r To Conduct U n i q u e R e f r i g e r a t i o n T r a i n i n g On G a s Tanker page: 77
- G r e a t Lake C a r r i e r s C o u l d G a i n From W o r l d T r a d e A g r e e m e n t s page: 77
- N e w Miller Brochure On XMT Inverters page: 78
- N e w Gulf Coast Marine Communications Service page: 78
- Pan-United Secures Major Tanker Contract page: 79
- Chemical Carriers Association Elects N e w Officers page: 79
- USCG Rules On Oil Spill Recovery Vessel Foreign Ownership page: 79
- Harris Introduces New Multiband, Multimission VHF/UHF Radio For Export Markets page: 80
- Shipping Business Booms Despite Soviet Breakup page: 81
- ABS Urges Side Stringers For Double Hulls page: 82
- Bender Shipbuilding To Convert Galena Eagle page: 82
- How The Oil Industry Did Financially In 1991 page: 83
- ECO-100 Pollution-Control Vessel Makes National Debut page: 84
- IMAS ' 9 2 To Be Held In Cyprus November 11-13, 1992 page: 86
- SWATH Cruise Ship Passes Sea Trials page: 87
- USCG/IMO To Hold Oil Spill R&D Seminar In Washington, June 1 -4 page: 87
- U.S.-Built NSF Research Icebreaker Begins Operation page: 88
- Marlow Ropes Offers Full Color, 36-Page Literature Package page: 89
- Brown Brothers Develops New Stabilizer System page: 89
- Avondale Boat Division Delivers New Tug To E.N. Bisso page: 90
- Free Color Brochure From ABB Marine Details Diesel Control page: 92
- Aqua-Chem Offers Brochure On Freshwater Equipment page: 92
- T-Torque's Drive System Available To Boat Builders, High-Speed Enthusiasts page: 92
- Free Brochure Offered On AutroMaster 3 0 0 0 Monitoring System page: 93
- Singmarine Launches Ore Carrier page: 94
- Schottel Rudderpropellers Offer Power, Maneuverability page: 96
- IDB Aero-Nautical Acquires Ocean Satellite Television page: 97
- VLCC ' N ew Venture7 Delivered By Ariake Works Of Hitachi Zosen page: 97
- World Shipbuilding Order Book Largest Since 1977 page: 98
- ISOPE 92 Scheduled For June 14-19, 1992 In San Francisco page: 98
- Textron Lycoming TF40 Marine Turbines Power New Megayacht Seawalker page: 99
- Trinity To Build Two Double-Hull Barges For Bouchard Transportation page: 99
- Gibbons Bill Pounded By South Atlantic And Caribbean Port Association page: 100
- USCG Prepares Overseas Maritime Training Team page: 100
- US Carriers Ask Government To Enforce Cargo Competition Rule page: 101
- Carnival Examines Future Ship Designs page: 101
- 'Spirit Of Norfolk' Delivered By Service Marine Industries page: 102
- Tampa Shipyards Christens First Of Two Navy Oilers page: 102
- Lamb Appointed To Oil Spill Oversight Council page: 103
- Marine Industries Northwest Installs Bowthruster In Freighter page: 103
- L&C Associates Provides D / H And Sealing System For Two Ships page: 103
- New Range Of Hold And Deck Coatings From International page: 104
- Aldenderfer Joins Trans-Tec Services As Managing Director page: 104
- Corroless Offers Owners Project Management, "Flying Squad'' Services page: 105
- Stolt Tankers And Terminals To Purchase Stolt-Nielsen Seaway page: 105
- Gladding-Hearn Delivers New Pilot Boat To Charleston, S.C. page: 112
- Toronto/St. Catharines Study Possible High-Speed Ferry page: 113
- Heavy Duty U.S. Pipe Bender Delivered To Italian Shipyard page: 113